Searching for Her Biological Father: Sylvia’s Unexpected Connection to Dean Nagler

The stranger who looked like my father

By the time Sylvia found Dean Nagler online, he was posting videos about the famous musicians he’d known in his prime: Eric Clapton, Frank Zappa, Pink Floyd. He sat in a home office lined with fading blue shelves and porcelain or bronze birds, leaning toward the camera in a gray T-shirt or sweatshirt, his receding hair tied back. His eyebrows jumped as he spoke. His hunger for approval was so exposed that Sylvia felt embarrassed on his behalf—and recognized something of her own desire in it. A commenter called him an idiot. Nagler had lost his medical license after administering anesthesia while high on fentanyl. He lived in upstate New York, resembled Sylvia, and was alleged to have played some part in the death of a famous pop star. He was also, Sylvia suspected, her biological father. The suspicion arrived in the summer of 2014, when Sylvia had just returned to New York from a postgraduate fellowship in the UK. Her mothers, Celeste and Lucia, sent her what she came to call the Dean Dossier: a jumble of screenshots, old news reports, a highlighted name in a book’s acknowledgments, and emails with their fertility doctor. They included a sketch Sylvia already knew—a profile of a young man who looked like Dean—and local reports naming the anesthesiologist on the pop star’s 1997 world tour. Their theory was that they’d found the man whose name Sylvia had been looking for. Nagler was easy to find. After losing his license, he volunteered at a bird sanctuary and posted videos about his years treating musicians. His Facebook page promised, “I respond to most messages within two hours.” Sylvia clicked a video about The Who. She’d spent years searching other men’s faces for traces of her own. Dean’s resemblance was immediate. That evening, before heading to a housewarming party with her roommate Tom, Sylvia messaged him. Her mother had been a patient of Dr. Nielson in 1989, she wrote. Had Dean ever donated sperm? Tom worked at McKinsey and had studied the Marxist influences on the American administrative state during the New Deal. Sylvia tutored online and was considering more school. They’d settled into a practical, companionable arrangement, with enough flirtation to make the boundaries interesting. On the elevator to the party, Dean replied: he had worked with Dr. Nielson, but had never donated sperm. He hoped Sylvia found what she was looking for. “My dad reached out to me,” Sylvia told Tom. He reminded her that she’d said she didn’t have a father. She answered that she did now. The reply was absurdly thin evidence, but the resemblance and the history had already taken hold. Sylvia imagined writing Dean a letter so persuasive he’d have to recognize her as his brilliant child. At the party, she told Tom about the dossier and the suspicion that Dean had been involved in a pop star’s death. Tom asked whether she planned to write again. Sylvia said probably not, then changed her mind on the cab ride home. Her message praised his videos about Duane Allman and the Fillmore East, and told him he seemed able to live with competing parts of himself. She admitted that lately she felt as if her identity and desires kept rewriting each other. The note was calculated flattery. Sylvia knew it, and felt a little ashamed of how directly she was appealing to Dean’s vanity. Still, his answer the next morning met her where she’d aimed: “My advice is be all of them. Being just one person has never appealed to me.” He said there was no need to choose; with ingenuity and stubbornness, a person could rearrange themselves. That advice suited Sylvia’s own attraction to changeability and a kind of easy nihilism. She’d noticed people talked to her more when she seemed unbothered by everything. She liked the feeling of being able to become many people. And yet Dean’s response didn’t prove the central claim. He might have been telling the truth about never donating sperm. Sylvia couldn’t know.

A DNA test, and another kind of family question

The morning after the party, Sylvia woke in Tom’s bed and imagined having someone in her corner—someone she could tell about Dean and about Tom. Her former college roommate, once her model for how to be a woman in the world, was no longer speaking to her. Tom teased Sylvia about the previous night, insisting he’d been chivalrous and that nothing had happened beyond a little drunkenness. Weeks later, Sylvia’s neighbor Molly offered a different route into the question of kinship. Molly lived across the hall, worked at a downtown jewelry store, and had a habit of getting locked out. She left Sylvia small gifts—popcorn, a cupcake, once a yoyo—and Sylvia thought of her as a wild crow trading treasures. In the laundry room, Molly said her sisters had sent her DNA tests because they suspected a hospital mix-up. She believed such mistakes happened more often than people assumed. Her sister put the rate at about one in a thousand; most were caught within days, but some surfaced years later, often when a father questioned whether a child looked like him. Molly offered Sylvia the spare test, suggesting they could spit into the cups, drink wine, and watch television. Sylvia had known a DNA kit could answer some questions. Her biological father’s identity had occupied her imagination for much of her first two decades. Her mothers had passed along the donor’s description from their doctor: tall, slim, young, with wavy brown hair; a doctor or medical student; Eastern European and Jewish. Sylvia also had a sketch her mother drew of a young man at the clinic. She’d spun whole imagined fathers from those scraps. The evidence connecting Dean to the donor was circumstantial. Sylvia’s mothers remembered a young man with a short ponytail entering a side room at the fertility clinic and emerging five minutes later. In 1989, health departments began requiring clinics to use frozen sperm, though some clinics resisted because they believed fresh sperm worked better. The nurse present had reportedly said the donor was an anesthesiologist. Dean was one too, and Sylvia’s mothers believed the man in the sketch matched images of him from CNN interviews after the pop star’s death. Sylvia had once convinced herself that an online acquaintance named Adelaide might be a half-sister, but that led only to awkward messages. Now there was Dean, and there was Molly’s test. Tom thought taking it might be foolish, but said she could do it as long as she didn’t get weird about the results. He wondered whether she might be attracted to her billions of potential half-siblings. Sylvia said no. The thought, she conceded, was disgusting.

A connection that resists a neat explanation

The narrator’s fixation on Molly begins to look less like curiosity and more like a search for family. The DNA kits may eventually answer whether they’re half-sisters, but the narrator already feels the pull of that possibility. She tells a stranger, “I’m just waiting for my sister,” and the words send a sharp thrill through her. The test results haven’t arrived. The feeling has. Molly’s story about her sisters supplying an extra kit falls apart when the narrator finds the receipt: Molly ordered both herself. That lie should create distance. Instead, the narrator treats it as permission to keep watching, gathering details from Molly’s social media, tracking her routines, even wearing clothes Molly left in the laundry. She knows the behavior is strange. She also recognizes its shape: it echoes the old obsession with an absent father, whom she once tried to assemble from imagined details until he might somehow love her. That parallel is more telling than the kits. The narrator has spent years wanting a family story with answers; now she’s building one around a woman who may or may not be her sister. Tom sees the danger in how completely she disappears into the search, but Molly gives her something the narrator’s solitary life in New York has been missing: a reason to imagine what might happen next. At the bar, the two women improvise a shared history to get Molly out of a bad date. The joke—dead sister, sick baby, absent father—lets them play at kinship without defining it. Later, over drinks, the narrator realizes her desire to know Molly has started to give way to something nearer to love. That doesn’t settle what they are to each other. The genetic attraction she read about at the start may be documented, but it can’t explain this particular bond, or tell either woman what to do with it. The story’s most unsettled question isn’t whether the test will confirm a biological link. It’s whether the narrator can meet Molly as a person, rather than as the answer to a lifelong mystery.

The post I Might Sleep With My Neighbor, If She Isn’t My Half-Sister appeared first on Electric Literature.